• smileyhead@discuss.tchncs.de
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    8 months ago

    If you did root your phone, you can turn RCS back on with the standard Magisk hiding procedures

    I really do not want to use hacks like that in order to send a text message.
    It reminds me of the:

    • Voting in elections now requires buying a Big Mac and having receipt for verification, I don’t want that.
    • No problem with that, just ask a friend to buy it for you. Or you can just fake

    A messaging standard that requires carrier, phone modem and phone operating system all implementing in order for it to work is outdated mindset from the era of flip-phones. We have Internet now, which allows sending any data to any device and we have installable apps that can send anything through it. Implementing an awful and already outdated standard in a most user freedom unfriendly manner just to replace even more outdated standard is not great.
    Imagine if Google now started promoting a FAX 2.0 protocol for fax machines, which would implement some of basic email features already being in email for 20. No, just use email and if your friends do not have it show them how to use it.

    • Skull giver@popplesburger.hilciferous.nl
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      8 months ago

      Well, if you can convince my carrier to embed XMPP into their texting network, I’d gladly take it over RCS. In practice, you can pick between “works on any phone” and “not designed for carriers”.

      Using the carrier standard is entirely optional. I only use it in extreme circumstances, like with outdated 2FA websites and when half a bar of 2G is all I can get. I like it that the built-in app will have modern features on any modern phone soon, but that’s about all I feel about it.

      If anything, the relative openness of RCS at least lets you write bots and other tools. There are a bunch of open source libraries that can communicate with RCS servers. Can’t say as much with WhatsApp (outside of the EU) and iMessage.