• 3 Posts
  • 18 Comments
Joined 3 months ago
cake
Cake day: August 11th, 2024

help-circle

  • For those interested in the answer, I quote an answer.

    Push notifications still go through Google’s servers just like with Play Services

    Yes; that’s unavoidable if you want to use applications that make use of them, as they send the notifications to Google server-side, you can’t just tell them to do it differently. If you want push notifications that don’t go through Google, you can use UnifiedPush, but then the apps must explicitly support it (it’s the case for a few apps on F-Droid).

    uses proprietary Google Binaries for some of its components such as DroidGuard

    Only for DroidGuard, which isn’t downloaded at all if you don’t enable SafetyNet. Your apps will also still include Google binaries of course.

    Choosing a network location like Mozilla to use with microG provides little to no privacy benefit over Google because you are still submitting the same data and trusting them to not profile you.

    That’s fairly subjective. You could trust Mozilla more than Google (but in any case Mozilla doesn’t provide its network location service any longer, you will have to use something like BeaconDB instead, and of course the same how’s for them), and you could still prefer for your location-related data to go to whoever they go without all the identifiers attached that Google gets, since microG doesn’t really tell them who you are aside from the unavoidable IP address.

    Finally, at least back in UnifiedNLP times, you could use location providers that weren’t actually “network” but let you download offline databases of cells instead. Unofrtunately, that sort of option is much more limited in current versions of microG.





  • Whilst I agree that IP search history is used, this isnt relevant here. We are merely talking via speech within the Signal phone app, then when ending the call and loading a youtube video, the recommended carousel will recommend multiple videos pertaining to things ONLY discussed in the call (never searched)

    More often than not its trivial things… IE mentioning to a friend the other day that I found a special security screw on the floor outside my house… After ending the call and loading a youtube song, My recommended feed shows numerous videos on special types of security screws… Something I havnt searched in over 3 years. Despite never logging into a google service in years, and good internet hygiene

    Another point : The recommended feed on matters discussed during the call dont persist for too long - IE the videos on security screws will be gone within a day, its blatantly obvious tbh.

    The instances I refer are too niche to be “coincidences”, more likely Google Violating their own sandboxing rules

    Also, I dont have a Wifi Router in my house.